By Elena Vasquez, Staff Writer
November 10, 2025

When Donald Trump addressed supporters in Florida on election night 2024, he hailed his victory as “an unprecedented and powerful mandate”—a sweeping endorsement from a nation weary of division. 9 Yet, as final tallies emerged, the reality painted a far more modest picture: a razor-thin popular vote edge and an Electoral College margin that, while decisive, hardly qualifies as resounding. Trump’s 49.9% to Kamala Harris’s 48.4%—a scant 1.5 percentage point lead—marks the third-narrowest winning margin since 1888, underscoring a deeply polarized electorate rather than a tidal wave of support. 6 This discrepancy isn’t mere semantics; it shapes how opposition voices frame their resistance, often diluting the urgency of labeling the GOP as an “American Fascist Party” in favor of safer, binary partisan talk.

Historical context reveals why “resounding” rings hollow. Trump’s 312-226 Electoral College haul, the widest since 2012, swept all seven battlegrounds by a collective 760,000 votes—impressive, yet dwarfed by landslides like Ronald Reagan’s 525-13 in 1984. 3 4 In the popular vote, he garnered 77.3 million ballots to Harris’s 75 million, a gain of 3 million from 2020 but still shy of a majority, with over 2 million votes for third parties. 2 Analysts at Pew Research attribute this to turnout shifts: Harris underperformed Biden’s 2020 totals by 6.3 million, while Trump consolidated gains among non-college-educated voters and minorities, flipping near-parity with Hispanics (48% to 51%) and doubling Black support to 15%. 5 7 It’s a victory forged in erosion, not exaltation—closer to George W. Bush’s contested 2004 win than Franklin D. Roosevelt’s transformative 1932 rout.

So why do Democratic spokespersons cling to “Democrats vs. Republicans” rhetoric, eschewing bolder fascist indictments? Partisan incentives loom large. Admitting the win’s narrowness risks demoralizing the base, while overhyping it as a rout invites GOP overreach, like aggressive policy pushes without broad buy-in. A Brookings analysis notes Trump’s popular vote lead mirrors Hillary Clinton’s 2016 edge—enough for a mandate claim, but not a blank check. 6 Figures like Chuck Schumer, in post-election briefings, emphasize “left-right divides” to rally moderates, fearing “fascist” labels alienate the 2% swing voters who tipped scales in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. 0 NPR’s post-mortem echoes this: the 1.5-point gap, the tightest since 1968, signals stasis, not seismic shift, making escalation feel premature. 2

Media complicity compounds the issue. Outlets like CNN and ABC, bound by “both-sides” norms, amplify Trump’s narrative to avoid bias accusations, even as polls showed half of Americans viewing him as fascist-adjacent. 8 This left-right framing sanitizes the GOP’s authoritarian drift—election denialism, loyalty purges—treating it as mere conservatism rather than a fascist inflection. As PolitiFact charts illustrate, Trump’s county-level gains were marginal, not revolutionary, yet pundits parrot “red wave” hyperbole. 4

The opposition’s timidity persists because a close win emboldens defensiveness: calling out fascism demands proof of dominance, not fragility. But history warns against complacency; narrow victories can entrench extremism, as in 1933 Germany. By November 2025, with Trump eyeing purges and tariffs, Democrats must pivot—from partisan patter to peril-naming—or risk ceding democracy’s defense to outdated dichotomies.

References

ABC News. (2024, November 26). The 2024 presidential election was close, not a landslide. https://abcnews.go.com/538/2024-presidential-election-close-landslide/story?id=116240898

Council on Foreign Relations. (2024, December 18). The 2024 election by the numbers. https://www.cfr.org/article/2024-election-numbers

NPR. (2024, December 3). Trump falls just below 50% in popular vote, but gets more than in past elections. https://www.npr.org/2024/12/03/nx-s1-5213810/2024-presidential-election-popular-vote-trump-kamala-harris

PBS News. (2024, November 24). The size of Donald Trump’s 2024 election victory, explained in 5 charts. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/the-size-of-donald-trumps-2024-election-victory-explained-in-5-charts

Pew Research Center. (2025, June 26). How changes in turnout and vote choice powered Trump’s victory in 2024. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/feature/how-changes-in-turnout-and-vote-choice-powered-trumps-victory-in-2024/

Pew Research Center. (2025, June 27). Behind Trump’s 2024 victory: Turnout, voting patterns and demographics. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2025/06/26/behind-trumps-2024-victory-a-more-racially-and-ethnically-diverse-voter-coalition/

The Nation. (2024, December 4). Donald Trump has NOT won a majority of the votes cast for president. https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/donald-trump-vote-margin-narrowed/

Wikipedia contributors. (2025, November 9). 2024 United States presidential election. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_States_presidential_election

Discover more from WPS News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.